Supreme Bakery

Luxurious Custom Cakes

Delicous Bakery Items

Enjoy at Our Bakery

Custom Cookies

Personalize Your Celebration



To Our Bakery

We are located at 40 Main Street, West Orange, NJ less than one mile from the
Thomas Edison house and museum. Supreme Bakery has been owned and operated by
the Stolz family since 1969. It has been our pleasure and privilege to be part of so many
family celebrations and memorable moments for the past 50 years. Our goal is to always
provide the freshest and finest desserts for all special moments.


Custom Cakes

Our custom designed cakes range from the simple and elegant to the extraordinary and extravagant. All cakes, large or small, are delicious as we do all baking and decorating on premises using the finest ingredients. We offer cake tastings where you can confer with one of our cake consultants to design your dream cake.

All Cake Types We Can Create

Ready To Enjoy

Tasty Treats

A short description will go here about the bakery items. A short description will go here about the bakery items. A short description will go here about the bakery items.A short description will go here about the bakery items. 



Designer cookies are a great addition to any special occasion. Wedding, baby showers, graduations, special birthdays, and anniversaries are all enhanced by an edible keepsake. Look through our picture gallery to get ideas and give a call to make an order. 10 day notice is required.


Supreme Bakery

We are located on Main Street in West Orange less than one mile from Thomas
Edison’s house and his invention factory. It is quite likely that the world’s greatest inventor was eating a Supreme Bakery glazed donut when he invented the light bulb. Since 1969, Supreme Bakery has been owned and operated by the Stolz family. It has been our goal to serve our customers the freshest and finest products possible. We have an experienced and dedicated staff who are eager to provide outstanding service. It is also our goal to be a contributing member of our community and take part in many charitable activities that benefit local organizations. Our favorite project is offering free cupcakes for grade school students who achieve A’s in major academic subjects. 

We are a Kosher Bakery under the supervision of Rabbi Bernhard Rosenberg. All of our baking is done on premise and is under the close supervision of certified Master Baker Richard Stolz.

Order Delivery

Order bakery goods on Uber Eats or DoorDash and have it delivered in minutes! 

West Orange's Favorite Bakery

We are honored to have been selected at Nextdoor’s Neighborhood Favorite Bakery! We love our community, thank you!


Close Menu


Order Online

Order a custom cake for any celebration. 

Order cupcakes for any celebration.

Order Delivery

Delivered to your door within minutes.

Attention Class of 2020

We are offering FREE Portraits and Graduation Cap and Diploma cake toppers for ALL custom Graduation cake orders.

After all of the hard work you have put in these last few years, a beautiful cake, specially made for you, is a great way to start off your celebration. This year, we want to celebrate all of you by giving back to our graduates.

(Portraits are printed edible images that are placed onto any cake. Portrait and toppers originally an additional $10 extra. Free of charge for a limited time only. Valid now until July 31st, 2020.)

Order a custom cake for any celebration.