Frequently Asked Questions

(Still need help? Call us at 973-736-1732)

Click on the toggle or question to reveal answer

You can place an order by scrolling over Cakes>Special occasion cakes>Cake order form. Then fill out the form and we will get back to you. Or you can call or come in store and one of our team Supreme members will walk you through the cake making process.

Cakes should be ordered at least 24 hours in advance. 

However, special occasion cakes must be ordered at least two weeks in advance, and specialty cookies must be placed at least 10 days in advance.

Please call the store at least two days before your order is set to be picked up so we can discuss the policy on cancellation.

Yes, we deliver specialty and catering orders to venues with an additional delivery fee starting at $25. Prices may vary based on the distance of your location.

We also offer delivery services through Ubereats, Doordash and Grubhub.

Please email orders@supremebakery.com to discuss a refund, and we will get back to you as soon as possible.

Please let us know prior to placing your order if there is any specific dietary restrictions that you, or your family may have.

We offer a select variety of items in gluten free and parve. Please call in store for more information.

Gluten free items must be placed at least 2 days in advance.

When it comes to sugar free, we have cakes and pies that can be made to order. 
Sugar free cakes are Whipped cream yellow cake only, with the option of either apple, cherry, or blueberry filling. Sugar free pies are also available in either apple, cherry or blueberry filling.

Close Menu
×

Cart

Order Online

Order a custom cake for any celebration. 

Order cupcakes for any celebration.

Order Delivery

Delivered to your door within minutes.